This blog is a random collection of information, partly in support of my quotations web site. Other topics include wine, military news, economics, history, libertarianism, and other random things which happen to strike my fancy. Backup site is at http://quotulatiousness.blogspot.com/ (if there are no posts showing, hit the backup blog for explanation). Comments have been turned off, as the spam was getting too much to handle. Comments can be emailed to me for posting.

May 30, 2006

Andrew recasts Godwin's Law for Canadian debaters

Jon sent this link to Bound by Gravity, where Andrew has performed a very useful transformation of Godwin's Law, specifically for Canadian content:

Godwin's Law, Canadian Variant:

As a online discussion about Canadian politics grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving the United States of America or a member of the Republican party approaches one.

Whenever a journalist, blogger, or commenter chimes in with a reductio ad americanum my respect for what they have written immediately drops a few notches, and I am less likely to take their point of view seriously. It is lazy rhetoric, and rarely appropriate. Even when the comparison is valid, the author's point could have been made (usually far more succinctly) using a different choice of words.

Bonus Snark:

Godwin's Law, Conservative/Libertarian Variant:

As a online discussion about left-versus-right politics grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving the USSR or Stalin approaches one.

Posted by Nicholas at May 30, 2006 11:09 AM
Comments


Visitors since 17 August, 2004